Which Mac Should I Get?

The strongest factors affecting my decision were:

• Cost. I wanted to spend as little as possible.
• Power usage. I live in a low-power environment and didn’t want to introduce a new device that was going to dramatically increase my electricity usage.

Clearly Apple Silicon was what I needed in terms of power. I’ve preferred ARM processors for years and use them for as much of my work as possible. Apple’s use of specialised ARM chips and tight control over their hardware/software architecture means they’re in a good position to maximise performance-per-Watt… if I must paddle in Apple’s pool, Apple Silicon is a no-brainer.

To keep it cheap, the obvious choice was to go with the first generation M1 chips. They reportedly still held up well and should get OS updates for a while (even longer with OpenCore Legacy Patcher).

I don’t love laptops (I’d rather choose my own keyboard, pointing device and screen so having redundant copies of these things stuck on my computer is a waste), so I was initially attracted to the M1 Mac Mini. It’s just a computer, without Human Interface Devices that I don’t need.

Two things put me off the M1 Mac Mini though:

It has a fan

People say it’s silent. Even if this is true (there are levels to this), fans are mechanical devices which can wear out (and develop a noise), suck/blow dust around (needing to be cleaned), or fail. They also use power.

Power delivery

The battery bank from which I power my home is 12V (24V or 48V would be better and I’ll upgrade when the time is right). All my electricity comes from this battery bank.

I have a power inverter, meaning I can use appliances with normal/household plugs, but the inverter wastes some power in the conversion process, stepping up from 12V to 220V. To then plug in a power brick, which will again throw away some power in converting 220V back down to whatever voltage a device uses, means double wastage, and a mess of plugs and wires.

I have DC 12V from the battery, and an easily-accessible 20V feed via a step-up converter. Then of course I have 5V over USB, not to mention all the exotic USB-C variants. Between all these methods I can power everything that I use regularly.

• Assorted XT-60 adapters

When I buy a new device the first thing I do is chop off its power connector, attach it to one of the XT60 connectors I use for everything , and chuck (hoard, actually) the device’s power brick. I’ve done this with multiple laptops and small form factor PCs without issue. They usually seem to want 19V-21V and be tolerant of 20V although I’ve heard stories of people damaging stuff with similar reckless behaviour to mine so maybe I’ve been lucky.

I searched for info about doing this with the M1 Mac Mini’s power brick and found some people saying they had problems. While writing this I just searched again to try to find those discussions but this time I found stuff suggesting it’s fairly easy. So I’m not sure if I used the wrong search terms before, or maybe I was just too jumpy about modding power delivery for an Apple device. Apple tends to be so unfriendly towards going off-road and they’re known for implementing measures to prevent you doing things in ‘unapproved’ ways. I didn’t want to waste money buying something I couldn’t use.

For better or worse, I decided against the M1 Mac Mini.